Abstract: On the second anniversary of G.N. Saibaba’s death, his life and writings remind us that scholarship and activism belong together. His idea of “subhumanity” links the violence of prison to the wider structures of caste and state power.
Two years have passed since the death of the former Delhi University professor G.N. Saibaba. His nearly 10-year incarceration, from 2014 to 2024, took a toll on his already 90 per cent disabled body. That a professor of repute, intellect, and empathy had to undergo such indignity and injustice at the hands of the justice system in India is not surprising any more. Many well-known academicians, poets, and students remain in jail under charges and legal cases that raise serious questions about the very meaning of justice.
Remembering Saibaba, then, is not merely an exercise in recalling an individual who suffered incarceration. It is an opportunity to understand the politics that shaped his life, the relationship between scholarship and activism that he embodied, and the criminal justice system that he spent his final years writing and speaking about. Saibaba’s own writings and speeches offer a way to understand this system through what he called “subhumanity”: a condition that, as I argue here, extends from the prison cell to the broader structures of caste, capital, state power, and social inequality. The same idea lets us ask what remembering Saibaba means for young scholar-activists today.
The scholar-activist
Saibaba was born into abject poverty and, until 2008, did not even have a wheelchair to move around. He used flip-flops on his hands to commute on all fours. Even so, he resolved to study and become a professor at Delhi University. His ambitions were never selfish, as his life demonstrates. He participated and organised at every chance he could. Despite capitalism’s deep intrusion into and structuring of the ivory towers of academia, people like Saibaba resisted the “publish or perish” pursuit of better pay and promotions to do worthwhile work and engage in scholarship.
Academia and activism are often projected as disconnected. Fascist governments and their media puppets also project activism as the opposite of intellectualism. For them, activism is smoking cigarettes and wearing short skirts on college campuses as shown in the state-propaganda movie, Jahangir National University (2024). Although cigarettes and short skirts are a strong symbolic way of protesting the moral order, academics who are activists and vice versa were never restricted to symbolism alone and moved into the terrain of action. Fascists branded this action-focused activism of scholars as terrorism. According to them, no researcher or teacher resorts to this activism/terrorism, for it is against the values of gurudom. When “urban Naxals” were derided in this country, it was not their intellectualism alone that threatened the government. It was their desire to change the world, a desire born out of their reading and their life circumstances.
For someone like Saibaba, politics, that is, speaking of freedom and equality, was never a choice. As a disabled person in a country where there is no infrastructure to make him free and equal, politics was inseparable from life itself. That is all he was doing: asking for a country that is truly free and equal for all. He had always been at the forefront of challenging the systems of oppression directed at the most marginalised: the Adivasis of India. He was a part of the All India People’s Resistance Forum, which was formed to oppose the liberalisation-globalisation-privatisation policies of the early 1990s. Naturally, he drifted into the politics of anti-displacement, for displacement is the first step of accumulation. He always insisted in his interviews and writings that struggles for equality and liberty are deeply connected.
Operation Green Hunt, for instance, was not merely a project to counter “leftist extremism". It was also, as history shows, a project to obliterate the forests to make way for mining, which is an environmental hazard. While several human rights scholar-activists in India have variously contributed to the chapters of the history of human rights in India, Saibaba’s contribution was extremely valuable and, for that reason, considered extremely dangerous by the state. He destabilised the state by questioning its foundational relationship to capital.
His numerous public meetings at the height of repression show that Saibaba was a “scholar-activist” in the truest sense. In her book Abolition Geography, the geographer Ruth Wilson Gilmore of the City University of New York discusses the term "scholar-activist". As a founding member of Critical Resistance and the California Prison Moratorium Project, and as a Black woman from a working-class family, she, like Saibaba, could never separate scholarly activity from her activist work. She organised and took part in a range of people’s movements.
Gilmore stated that scholar-activism is the coupling of rigorous and engaged academic analysis with organising, so that scholarship and organising inform and sharpen each other. This is closely aligned with, but also twists, what Marx said in Theses on Feuerbach (1845): “Philosophers have hitherto only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it.” Gilmore twisted it to argue that the interpretation of the world and the changing of the world should be simultaneous, because if they are not, it is merely knowledge production at the cost of people’s misery, or merely misguided politics. Such neutral and dissociated knowledge production is nothing but exploitation. If academicians who write and lecture about genocide, the environment, justice, and such topics stay silent in the face of the oppression that their subjects are undergoing, that is exploitation. Saibaba never rebelled in silence.
In fact, in an interview published in Rediff.com in 2016, Saibaba was asked if he felt like giving up the fight against the state for he was incarcerated twice so far. To that, he candidly replied: "But will I forgive myself? How can any democratic-minded person not speak out against the genocide of Adivasis? How can we be silent when we see millions of Adivasis being displaced? Do we have a choice whether to speak or not?"
This commitment to others also shaped the way Saibaba spoke about incarceration. After his own imprisonment, he spoke at length about ordinary inmates incarcerated under varied charges, charges they do not understand, and charges they cannot get rid of. Pandu Narote, his co-accused, was one such person, arrested under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). A young Adivasi man who did not even understand what the judgment meant and had never met Saibaba before, Narote was a victim of the state’s ploy to capture the “urban naxals".
Saibaba was never simply a victim. He was an engaged scholar. And it is precisely as a scholar-activist that Saibaba gives us a way to understand the justice system in India: not justice, not fairness, but what he termed in his press conference "subhumanity".
Subhumanity and the law
Having borne witness to the torture, cruelty, and “subhuman conditions” prevalent in today’s Indian prisons, Saibaba took every chance to write and speak about the prison system. In March 2024, the Bombay High Court acquitted Saibaba of all charges. He then addressed the media, whom he profusely thanked for speaking truth to power. In his speech, he spoke of the ordinary people in prison and of his former lawyer, Surendra Gadling, who was still in jail. He gave them priority even over the loss of his mother while he was in jail, and over the grave inhumanity of the justice system in India, which did not let him see his mother when she died.
All the available written and oral records left by Saibaba give us a concept for better understanding our justice system. Between 2014 and 2022, over 8,700 people were arrested under the UAPA. This Act shifts the burden of proof onto the accused and gives unchecked powers to detain anybody at will. Since fairness and the rule of law no longer govern our justice system, it is rather impossible to understand what scholars and activists are even dealing with. I think it is possible to develop a concept of “subhumanity” by reconstructing the varied dimensions and signposts that combine to make it.
Saibaba repeatedly said that the prison was subhuman. When he said it, he referred to many things, primary among them medical neglect. According to Saibaba, he had to watch his co-accused Narote die, bleeding from his eyes, right in front of him. The tests on this (legally) innocent man later showed that an easily preventable and curable disease, swine flu, had taken his life. This anecdote could easily be matched with the available statistics on mortality and diseases in Indian jails. For instance, the National Crime Records Bureau’s pre-Covid Prison Statistics India 2017 shows that 1,671 prisoners died in judicial custody, 1,494 of them from natural causes. Between 2017 and 2022, 11,289 custodial deaths were reported. Subhumanity, then, is a deliberate, intense, and frequent neglect of health to such an extent that loss of life is inevitable and imposed upon prisoners.
Yet, for Saibaba, subhumanity was not limited to medical neglect. Although he explicitly associated subhumanity with the prison, he made sure to state that this condition is carried out only when the prison department, the government, the police, the courts, and the media work together. Dissecting Saibaba’s case alone, we can see the unity of these technically different institutions.
The unjust judgment, in which the judge himself said that life imprisonment was not sufficient punishment and that the “hands of the Court are tied” because it was the maximum the law provided, tells us how courts worked with the police and their bosses in the government to reduce Saibaba to a state of subhumanity. Inside the prison, Saibaba was not even able to use the washroom comfortably, given his disabilities. He was placed in the anda (egg-shaped) cell, to confine him in solitary and prevent him from engaging with people. Life-saving medicines were also denied for the newer ailments he was developing while inside the prison. And yet, the mainstream media ran a trial and branded him a terrorist: constructing both his guilt and public outrage. Saibaba described this unity of supposedly different departments in his essay for Frontline.
He wrote about the police influencing the prison rules on the treatment of prisoners and the punishments given to them inside the prison. None of these police visits to the prison, he maintained in his writings, were recorded in the jail books, bypassing the rule of law.
The subhumanity of this system is also closely tied to the caste system in India. The Supreme Court’s judgment in Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India (2024) brought the systemic caste inequalities in the jails of post-colonial India into public view. These, as the journalist Sukanya Shantha showed in her investigative report, were embedded in the prison manuals first drafted during the colonial era. The British salvaged the pre-modern caste categories to better establish their capitalist exploitation in India. Indian jails became the breeding grounds for capitalist accumulation: directly through the jail industries, and indirectly through a repressive control over resistances of all kinds outside the walls of jails.
The institutions founded on these principles continued to incarcerate disproportionate numbers of “SCs, STs, minorities, and OBCs”, as Saibaba himself observed when in jail. Statistics also correspond with his observation: IndiaSpend reports that between 2002 and 2019, two out of every three undertrials in India belonged to marginalised caste groups.
Nor is that the only way caste structures our subhuman justice system. It also structures the way prisoners are treated, denying them basic dignity and humiliating them to social death. Saibaba said that 3,200 prisoners sleep in a place that can accommodate only 1,500, forcing them to fight one another “like animals”. Mentally ill prisoners were sometimes seen handcuffed to railings and trees, howling and crying in sadness and panic.
And, of course, prisoners are beaten black and blue for no good reason. Saibaba wrote of an incident where an illiterate Muslim fellow-prisoner was beaten up for allegedly writing a “love letter” to a female staff member. How can an illiterate person even write one? It does not matter to an institution that is hell-bent on perpetuating subhumanity.
Beyond the prison walls
The subhumanity extends beyond the prison walls. Saibaba had always questioned this subhumanity: the collusion of state institutions that had humiliated Indians, endangered their health, and caused their deaths all through his scholarly career. His appointment as an assistant professor at Ram Lal Anand College, Delhi University, was never separate from his tireless activism, just as going to school in today’s India is not separate from protesting its subhuman conditions.
On October 12, the second anniversary of his death, India is witnessing continuing unrest to save Indian democracy. Saibaba was part of this history of protest in India. He was branded a terrorist, like Bhagat Singh nearly a century ago, for his mere participation.
Remembering Saibaba is furthering his legacy of speaking about the most marginalized and those rendered voiceless by the state media despite their active protest. Remembering Saibaba, then, is participating in these protests, such as the data centre protests in Visakhapatnam and the protests seeking the Chief Election Commissioner’s resignation. Remembering Saibaba is extending solidarity to protests against the Ken-Betwa river linking and to those protesting the climate-catastrophic mining and deforestation.
Remembering Saibaba also means identifying the issues that especially affect those whose conditions are completely in dark due to the colonial legacies of the Indian legal system: those thousands of innocent prisoners who, for reasons of destitution, illiteracy, and political beliefs, languishing in jails while they shouldn’t be!
Remembering Saibaba, finally, is remembering what his life demonstrated about scholarship itself: that questioning the world and working with people to make it a better place need not be separate acts. It is remembering the scholar-activist, the prisoner who spoke for other prisoners, and the thinker who gave us the language of “subhumanity” to understand the institutions that produced his own suffering.
Remembering Saibaba is remembering that he refused to die, and that he is ever present in all struggles for justice.
Written by - Vipanchika S. Bhagyanagar is a PhD candidate in history at Purdue University, West Lafayette. Her research focuses on caste and colonial carcerality in India in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. She translated stories for the Revolutionary Writers’ Association’s book series Viyyukka, an anthology of women revolutionaries in contemporary India.
First published in Frontline on 12th of October, 2026: https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/gn-saibaba-india-justice-system-subhumanity-prison-caste/article71546254.ece